CHARLOTTESVILLE — Albemarle County Public Schools closed all of its schools to students on Thursday after finding that 524 employees hired over the past three years were never screened against Virginia's Child Protective Services Central Registry, a check that state law and School Board policy require for new hires.
All 524 passed a fingerprint based criminal background check through the Virginia State Police. What never happened was the second screening, a search of the registry kept by the Virginia Department of Social Services, which lists people with founded complaints of child abuse or neglect. A founded complaint is a finding by social services investigators, not a criminal conviction.
Acting Superintendent Chandra Hayes announced the closure in a letter to families on Wednesday afternoon. "Families should not have to accept any uncertainty about the adults working with their children, and I will not risk the safety of our students," she wrote. Because the unscreened employees work in schools and departments across the whole division, every school had to close until the checks are done. The Virginia Department of Education, which the division notified, agreed that staff who work directly with children must finish the screening before they can work with students again.
Schools are closed to students from Thursday, November 19, through the Thanksgiving break. Thursday and Friday are teacher workdays, with teachers posting lessons students can do on their own on Friday. The whole division is closed Monday and Tuesday, November 23 and 24, followed by the Thanksgiving break. The division hopes to reopen on Monday, November 30, and will confirm that date by Friday, November 27. The missed days will not have to be made up. Cafeterias serve lunch from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. Thursday and Friday.
Social Services has put the Albemarle searches first, starting with employees who work directly with students, and Hayes said it will work through the weekend. Division staff drove the paperwork to Richmond on Thursday morning; communications director Jason Grant put the pace at about 100 records a day. By Thursday evening, 186 of the 524 screenings were done, and every one came back clear. "All 186 came back clear, with no findings of child abuse or neglect," Hayes told families. About 338 remained, and until their checks are finished, those employees cannot be around students, including at weekend school events.
Hayes said the failure turned up in a review of hiring procedures begun after she took over the division. The criminal checks were done, she wrote, but "the personnel responsible for submissions to Child Protective Services did not consistently follow established processes," so the hires' information was never sent to Social Services. She told reporters Wednesday night that the employees responsible have been identified and the division has taken action under its policies. She also confirmed that none of the 524 is under investigation or facing charges related to abuse, neglect or failure to report.
The School Board met in a special session Wednesday evening, most of it behind closed doors, and backed Hayes afterward. "Dr. Hayes has our 150% support on this," said Rebecca Berlin, the board's chair. "She made the right call. She put students first." Mary McIntyre, president of the Albemarle Education Association, said Thursday that closing until every check is complete "was the cautious call," while adding that "this is a situation that should never have happened." She said the unscreened employees had done everything asked of them, and the failure sat with the administration.
Gov. Abigail Spanberger blamed the division's former leadership. "They failed to follow the law by not conducting legally-required background checks, and they failed to uphold the trust our commonwealth placed in them," she said in a statement Wednesday. Rep. John McGuire called the situation "outrageous and unacceptable" in a Facebook post on Thursday.
Parents scrambled for child care. "As a single parent, I have to go to work because I have deadlines," said Rashmi Ghei, a division parent. "If I cannot work, then I don't get paid. My limited leave hours will not cover this unexpected closure."
The discovery lands on a division already in crisis. Over the summer, former elementary school coach Michael Swiney was indicted on felony charges of sexual crimes involving children; police say the case now covers 20 counts and at least seven victims. Three administrators have been charged with failing to report suspected abuse, the former superintendent resigned in June, and three School Board members have resigned. State education officials have worked with the division since October and ordered an outside review of its reporting policies and culture.
If a remaining screening finds a founded complaint against a current employee, Hayes said the division will act at once; Board policy requires dismissal once the employee's appeal rights under state law run out. So far, no screening has come back with a problem.
Reporting note: This story is based on Acting Superintendent Chandra Hayes's November 18 letter to families and the division's screening tracker, both published by Albemarle County Public Schools, and on reporting by Charlottesville Tomorrow, Cville Right Now, the Staunton News Leader, WVIR and Virginia Scope.
