NEW ORLEANS — The House of Representatives unconstitutionally passed a $1.7 trillion government funding bill in 2022 through a pandemic era rule that allowed lawmakers to vote by proxy rather than in person, a federal appeals court ruled on Friday, according to Reuters.
The New Orleans based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals voted 9 to 8 to uphold an injunction that outgoing Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton secured blocking enforcement of a provision of that measure that gave pregnant workers stronger legal protections. The provision is the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which requires employers to offer reasonable accommodations to pregnant employees. Read the Reuters report here.
The majority held that the proxy rule violated the Constitution’s Quorum Clause, which the court said requires a majority of House members to be physically present to pass legislation. “While the chambers of the legislature have much discretion regarding their rules of procedure, the Quorum Clause’s constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat,” wrote U.S. Circuit Judge Cory Wilson, an appointee of President Donald Trump.
The spending bill passed the House on a 225 to 201 vote, with 226 members voting by proxy, and was signed into law by President Joe Biden. The proxy rule was dropped when Republicans took control of the House after the November 2022 elections.
While the decision concerns how the entire bill was passed, the relief the court granted was narrow. It barred the Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant workers provision against Texas. It did not strike down the rest of the spending package.
In dissent, U.S. Circuit Judge James Graves, an appointee of President Barack Obama, called the ruling illogical, inexplicable and invalid. He said the majority read a physical presence requirement into the Quorum Clause that does not exist, and gave no explanation for why, if the whole law was unconstitutionally passed, the ruling should be limited to one small part of the bill.
Background: a federal district judge ruled for Texas in 2024. A Fifth Circuit panel later found that Congress acted within its authority when it created the proxy voting rule, but that decision was vacated when the full court agreed to hear the case. The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386.
What happens next: the ruling is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court, according to Bloomberg Law, and it could open the door to new challenges to other laws enacted during the pandemic era using proxy voting. For now, the direct effect is limited to enforcement of the pregnant workers law against Texas, but the reasoning reaches the way Congress passed a much larger package of legislation.
