Senate Panel Advances Trump’s FCC Nominee 15 to 0 After Every Democrat Boycotts the Vote

Headline card: Senate Panel Advances Trump FCC Nominee 15 to 0 After Every Democrat Boycotts the Vote

The Senate Commerce Committee advanced FCC nominee Danielle Thumann Severs 15 to 0 after every Democrat boycotted the vote.

WASHINGTON — The Senate Commerce Committee voted 15 to 0 on Wednesday to advance Danielle Thumann Severs, a top aide to Federal Communications Commission Chair Brendan Carr, for a seat on the commission, after every Democrat on the panel boycotted the meeting.

Severs is a senior counsel to Carr. President Donald Trump nominated her in August for one of the commission's two open seats, the one left empty when Republican Commissioner Nathan Simington resigned in June 2025. The Democratic side of the hearing room sat empty on Wednesday. All 15 Republicans were there, and they approved her nomination without a single Democratic vote.

"Today is November 18th"

Democrats had written to Chairman Ted Cruz of Texas the day before, asking him to pull the nomination from the agenda. Cruz refused and opened the meeting by pointing at the empty seats. "Apparently, that means the Democrats don't need to show up for work anymore," he said.

"Democrats will control the Senate, unfortunately, in January, but today is November 18th," Cruz said. "The American people elected each of us to fulfill our duties, including advice and consent for our full terms."

Democrats said they had hoped their absence would deny Republicans the number of members needed to hold a vote. It did not work, because the Republicans on the panel were enough on their own.

Why Democrats stayed away

The committee's Democrats, led by Senator Maria Cantwell of Washington, said any Republican nominee to the FCC should be paired with a new term for Commissioner Anna Gomez, the commission's only Democrat, and with a Democratic nominee for the commission's other open seat. "This is not a problem we created, but a problem that the White House can solve," they said.

Democrats on the committee also say they fear what could happen after Severs is seated. The Supreme Court ruled this year, in a case called Trump v. Slaughter, that the president has the power to fire members of independent agencies. Democrats say Trump could use that power to remove Gomez once Severs gives Republicans a third seat, leaving the commission with three Republicans and no Democrat at all.

Cruz answered that Trump has not fired any FCC commissioner. Simington and Commissioner Geoffrey Starks, he noted, both resigned on their own in June 2025, and Severs would simply replace a Republican with a Republican.

A fight over her testimony

A second dispute is about whether Severs told the truth at her confirmation hearing last week. She testified that she had not worked with Carr on any media related issues.

Senator Ben Ray Luján of New Mexico, the top Democrat on the panel's telecom subcommittee, wrote to Cruz this week citing internal FCC emails that the advocacy group Protect Democracy obtained under the Freedom of Information Act. According to Luján, the emails show that Severs helped edit wording in July 2025 about diversity commitments Skydance made while seeking approval to buy Paramount, helped process informal complaints accusing CBS's "60 Minutes" of distorting the news, and took part in internal talks about how the agency would respond to viewers after Carr threatened broadcasters over late night host Jimmy Kimmel.

"It appears that Ms. Thumann misled the Committee and offered false testimony," Luján wrote. He asked Cruz to postpone the vote and hold another hearing so Severs could answer the questions.

The FCC pushed back. "The letter mischaracterizes the situation and facts entirely," an FCC spokesperson said, adding that her testimony was truthful and that she never met with anyone from Skydance or other outside parties. In written answers sent to senators this week, Severs said she sometimes works on issues that cross into other areas, but added: "I did not have any conversations with Paramount, CBS, or Skydance related to the merger."

Free Press Action, an advocacy group that opposes the nomination, accused Severs of misleading lawmakers. "Senator Cruz could have paused, investigated and asked more questions," said Jessica J. González, the group's co-CEO. "Instead, he sent Thumann Severs to a Senate floor vote."

Why one seat matters

The FCC is the federal agency that licenses television and radio stations to use the public airwaves, approves or blocks big media mergers, and writes rules for broadcasters, phone companies and internet providers. It has five seats, and by law no more than three can belong to the president's party. Only three commissioners are serving now: Carr and Commissioner Olivia Trusty, both Republicans, and Gomez, a Democrat.

If Severs is confirmed, Carr would have a 3 to 1 Republican majority. One live question before the commission is the fate of Disney's eight company owned ABC stations. The FCC ordered an early review of their licenses in April, a day after Trump called for Kimmel to be fired. Disney has sued to block the review, and a federal judge has not yet ruled. Licenses are almost never taken away, but critics say the threat alone can pressure stations over what they broadcast.

What happens next

The nomination now goes to the full Senate. Radio Ink reported that no date for that vote had been set as of Wednesday. Republicans hold the Senate for the rest of this year, but Democrats take control of both chambers of Congress in January after this month's elections. If the Senate does not confirm Severs before then, her nomination would sit with a Democratic majority that has already said it wants her paired with Democratic nominees.

Reporting note: This story is based on reporting by Reuters, Politico, The Desk and Radio Ink on the November 18, 2026 committee vote, the Senate Commerce Committee's release of Chairman Ted Cruz's remarks, Senator Ben Ray Luján's letter as reported by Politico, and statements from committee Democrats and Free Press Action.

Share this story

See an error? Contact Zark News.