VIRGINIA — Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent attacked Gov. Abigail Spanberger on Sunday, accusing her on X of "slamming the door on education scholarships for Virginia children, including students in PUBLIC schools." The posts came two days after Spanberger said Virginia would not take part in the program's first year. Bessent argued Virginia had already chosen to participate and that federal law requires her to finish the enrollment. Former Gov. Glenn Youngkin pressed the same case. Spanberger's office has not publicly answered Bessent. The fight centers on one filing, a state list of scholarship organizations due at the IRS by February 15, 2027.
How the program works
Congress created the Education Freedom Tax Credit in 2025, as Section 25F of the tax code. It starts on January 1, 2027. A taxpayer can give cash to a scholarship granting organization, a nonprofit that turns donations into scholarships for K-12 students, and get every dollar back as a credit against federal taxes, up to $1,700 for one person or $3,400 for a married couple filing jointly. The scholarships can pay private or religious school tuition. They can also pay for tutoring, special needs services, transportation and other help for students who stay in public school. A student qualifies if the household earns no more than 300 percent of the area median income, which the Treasury Department estimates covers about 96 percent of children. The money comes from private donations, not state budgets. But scholarships can only go to students in states that opt in, and each state must send the IRS a list of the organizations that qualify there.
Youngkin signed Virginia up. Spanberger stopped the enrollment.
Virginia was the first state in the country to opt in. In January, days before leaving office, Youngkin filed Virginia's advance election with the Treasury Department and named about a dozen organizations he expected to qualify. His office says he completed every step that existed at the time; the IRS did not open the system for the final list until after he left office. Spanberger, a Democrat who had promised to reject efforts to divert funding from public education to voucher programs, kept the question open for most of 2026. In late October, the IRS wrote to her office to say the election was still not complete. On November 13, her office told The Washington Post that the administration "at this point, does not believe this program would benefit students in public schools, and the Commonwealth will not be participating this year."
Does the law make her finish it?
Bessent says the choice is no longer hers. "Virginia has already chosen to participate in 2027, and @GovernorVA is required under federal law to complete the administrative procedure," he wrote. "Spanberger: certify the scholarship organizations. Stop playing politics with children's futures." His strongest point: Virginia's name is on the IRS list of participating states, because Youngkin's election is on file there. The Treasury regulations say a state "must perfect its election by providing its State SGO list," and Bessent reads "must" as an order. But the same regulations say a state that never sends the list is treated as not having elected to take part, and they set no penalty for staying out. Law firm analyses describe participation as voluntary for states, and the election is made each year by the sitting governor, unless state law names someone else. In short, Youngkin's signature started an enrollment, but the rules leave the last step to the governor in office.
What it means for Virginia in 2027
If nothing changes, no Virginia student can receive one of these scholarships in 2027, because no Virginia organization will be on the federal list. Virginia's public schools enroll about 1.25 million students; Youngkin put the number of students counting on the governor at 1.4 million in all. Virginians can still claim the credit by donating in the 30 other participating states, but their money would fund scholarships for children there. Education writer Chad Aldeman wrote that a Virginia Tutoring Fund he was helping to set up for students in high-poverty public schools now cannot help Virginia students unless the governor opts in.
Reaction on both sides
Supporters reacted angrily. Zack Roday, an adviser to Youngkin, called the decision a "betrayal" of voters. Sydney Altfield of Teach Coalition estimated it could have brought Virginia children about $1.5 billion in scholarship money. Democrats for Education Reform estimated that if 15 percent of eligible Virginia taxpayers donated, the program would generate about $766 million in the state. Both numbers are supporters' estimates, not official figures. The Virginia Education Association, the state's largest teachers union, had urged Spanberger in October not to file the list. Its president, Carol Bauer, said the governor "can keep Virginia from taking on this additional risk." The union warned that if the program draws students and support away from public schools, a drop of 4 percent in public school operating support would mean about $940 million less a year statewide. In Chesapeake, the school board voted 7 to 2 in October to back participation. Democratic governors in Colorado, New York and New Mexico have opted their states in.
What happens next
The decision can still change. The window to send the list stays open until February 15, 2027, and Spanberger's office described her position as one held "at this point," for "this year." If no list arrives by the deadline, Virginia is treated as not taking part in 2027, and the same choice returns for 2028. A carried over General Assembly bill, HB 359, would set state rules for private schools in the program.
Reporting note: This story is based on The Washington Post's November 13, 2026 report of the governor's decision; the posts on X by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and former Gov. Glenn Youngkin on November 15, 2026; Internal Revenue Service and Treasury Department releases and regulations for Section 25F, including the temporary regulations (T.D. 10057) and Revenue Procedure 2026-6; the Virginia Education Association's October 2, 2026 statement; Jewish Insider reporting; WHRO coverage of the Chesapeake School Board; legal analyses by the Williams Mullen law firm and EducationCounsel; and education writer Chad Aldeman's November 14, 2026 newsletter.
