Senate Rejects Iran War Powers Measure 48-51 as Republicans Hold for Trump

The United States Capitol in Washington

File photo: the United States Capitol in Washington, D.C. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

WASHINGTON — The Senate has rejected a measure that would have directed President Donald Trump to remove U.S. forces from hostilities against Iran unless Congress authorized them, defeating the House-passed resolution by 48 votes to 51 on November 19, according to the Senate’s official floor record.

The resolution, H.Con.Res. 93, invoked section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution, the 1973 law meant to keep Congress involved in decisions to wage war. It passed the House on September 15 by 220 votes to 204 and was referred to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in September, according to the House clerk’s records. Its defeat in the Senate stopped the directive from gaining the approval of both chambers. The vote itself gave the president no new legal authority for military action. Read the vote record summary here.

Three Republicans, Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky, voted for the measure, while John Fetterman of Pennsylvania was the only Democrat to vote against it, according to the floor record. Chris Murphy of Connecticut did not vote. USA Today reported that several Republicans who had backed earlier war powers efforts, including Thom Tillis of North Carolina and Josh Hawley of Missouri, opposed this measure on process grounds rather than on its substance.

The vote was the first of its kind in Congress since the midterm elections, which were widely read as a repudiation of the Iran war and its economic costs, according to USA Today. The United States has carried out several attacks on Iranian military targets in recent days, including a strike on November 17 against a missile launch site on Iran’s Qeshm Island, the paper reported. Democratic sponsors have forced repeated war powers votes this year, and support for them has grown slowly, but not yet to a majority in the Senate.

Supporters of the resolutions argue that the Constitution gives Congress, not the president, the power to declare war, and that a conflict now months old, with strikes, blockades and attacks on shipping, cannot rest on presidential authority alone. Opponents argue that the measures are political messaging that would tie the president’s hands without changing the facts on the ground, and that a concurrent resolution of this kind would not in any case be legally enforceable against the president.

The defeat leaves the legal argument unresolved. Democrats have vowed to keep forcing votes, and the question is likely to return to the floor of the new Congress in January, when the parties’ numbers will have changed after the midterms. For now, the administration retains a free hand in the conflict, and the Senate has again declined to order it to stop.

Share this story

See an error? Contact Zark News.